He was a visitor
John Holland Horton was born in 1872 at Ingatestone, Essex, England, the son of Anne Elizabeth and George Gibson Horton, a Congregational Minister. The April 2nd 1911 UK Census shows him as a 39 year old ‘Commercial Traveller, Education’, working for International Correspondence Schools Ltd. (A company founded in the USA that still exists today.)
We believe John may have come to Melbourne in December 1913 aboard the Orsova.
He lied about his age!
John enlisted in the Australian Imperial Force on 2nd November 1914. Despite being 42 at the time he stated he was 37yrs and 6mths, presumably to get under the maximum enlistment age of 38yrs.
We know from his enlistment that John was 5′ 10 3/4″ weighed 11st 8lbs, was of Fair complexion with Grey eyes and Sandy hair and had tattoos on both forearms.
Private John Horton was enlisted into the 5th Infantry Battalion, 2nd Reserves, and eventually was posted to ‘C’ Company. He embarked from Melbourne on 2nd Feb 1915 on H.M.A.T. A46 “Clan MacGillivray”
5th Infantry Battalion A.I.F.
“The 5th Battalion was among the first infantry units raised for the AIF during the First World War. Like the 6th, 7th and 8th Battalions it was recruited from Victoria and, together with these battalions, formed the 2nd Brigade.
The battalion was raised within a fortnight of the declaration of war in August 1914 and embarked just two months later. After a brief stop in Albany, Western Australia, the battalion proceeded to Egypt, arriving on 2 December. It later took part in the ANZAC landing on 25 April 1915, as part of the second wave. It was led by Lieutenant Colonel D. S. Wanliss, the officer who had raised the battalion. Ten days after the landing the 2nd Brigade was transferred from ANZAC to Cape Helles to help in the attack on the village of Krithia. The attack captured little ground but cost the brigade almost a third of its strength. The Victorian battalions forming the 2nd Brigade returned to ANZAC to help defend the beachhead, and in August the 2nd Brigade fought at the battle of Lone Pine. The battalion served at ANZAC until the evacuation in December.
After the withdrawal from Gallipoli, the battalion returned to Egypt and, in March 1916, sailed for France and the Western Front.”
Source: AWM Unit Histories. for more go HERE
What happened to 5th Battalion at The Landing at Gaba Tepe?
We don’t know exactly what happened to John Horton. We presume he landed on the northern end of the front with the 5th Battalion and 2nd Brigade Headquarters from the Novian which was late to reach the “Beach” on the morning of the 25th of April. The Novian was meant to precede the Galeka containing the 6th and 7th Battalions but ended up landing after them.
A detailed description of The 2nd Brigade’s day on April 25th 1915 is contained in C.E.W. Bean’s Official History of Australia in the War of 1914-1918 Vol.1 Chapter XVII – The Second Brigade on the “400 Plateau”. It makes for fairly grueling reading and other Chapters can be found at the Australian War Memorial site HERE.
We do know:
We know John Horton was wounded at Gaba Tepe and was cleared from the battle on the Lützow.
On the 27th of April 1915 the Lütsow, Itonus, Ionian, Clan Macgillivray, and Seang Choon with 2,500 wounded were sent off to Alexandria.
“Aboard the improvised “hospital carriers” conditions existed which may scarcely be described. The Clan Macgillivray and the Seang Choon were probably the best staffed of the original transports. Yet the Clan Macgillivray carried 850 wounded with only two doctors, and the Seang Choon, packed in every space with from 600 to 800 wounded, had only three. The broken men were lucky if they had a hard table to lie on for the next four days, with lifebelts for pillows. The endless stamping of horses in the Lütsow prevented sleep. The Derfflinger, despite the protest of Major Millard that she was overcrowded, took 500 cases, and sailed with three doctors to Alexandria. By the second day at sea thirty men had died aboard her. In the Mashobra many of the wounded had no blankets and no food. In some ships there were no conveniences at all, and newspapers had to serve for utensils of health and cleanliness. In the Lütsow not even paper was obtainable, and there were only four bed-pans, stolen from another ship, for nearly 800 patients.
From Bean’s Official History Vol 1 Ch 25 The Clearing of the Wounded HERE
John Horton was admitted to No.15 General Hospital, Alexandria Egypt on 30th April 1915.
4th May 1915
On 4th May 1915 at 11:30pm Private John Holland Horton died of wounds to the spine.
John was buried in the Alexandria (Chatby) Military and War Memorial Cemetery in Egypt on 5th May 1915.
His headstone reads:
“DEATH DIVIDES BUT MEMORY CLINGS”
The connection we have to John Horton is a letter in his personnel records held at The National Archive. The letter is from C.H.Morgan to the Army requesting an address for John Horton’s next of kin. Apparently the Shire was presenting certificates to all those that enlisted from the area and the letter suggests that John Horton was at Portsea when he enlisted.
There is more to learn about this Englishman that came to our country, joined our forces and died fighting with our countrymen all in the space of seventeen months.
Return to LEST WE FORGET